<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><testsuites name="pytest tests"><testsuite name="pytest" errors="0" failures="2" skipped="4" tests="43" time="1284.387" timestamp="2026-11-03T20:36:39.964112+00:00" hostname="ai-gateway-controller-group99cdc8f95b30cadca212c485732db87d-pod"><testcase classname="tests.test_api_keys.TestAPIKeySubscriptionPhases" name="test_create_key_for_pending_subscription" time="34.017" /><testcase classname="tests.test_api_keys.TestAPIKeySubscriptionPhases" name="test_reject_key_for_unreconciled_subscription" time="17.058" /><testcase classname="tests.test_negative_security.TestAuthPolicyRemoval" name="test_authpolicy_deletion_revokes_access" time="18.748" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestSubscriptionEnforcement" name="test_auth_pass_no_subscription_gets_403" time="1.047" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestSubscriptionEnforcement" name="test_rate_limit_exhaustion_gets_429" time="19.418" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestSubscriptionEnforcement" name="test_models_endpoint_exempt_from_rate_limiting" time="18.821" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestMultipleSubscriptionsPerModel" name="test_user_in_one_of_two_subscriptions_gets_200" time="10.711" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestUnlimitedSubscription" name="test_unlimited_and_token_rate_limits_are_mutually_exclusive" time="0.565" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestUnlimitedSubscription" name="test_unlimited_key_is_not_rate_limited" time="21.584" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestUnlimitedSubscription" name="test_unlimited_subscriptions_share_one_wasm_limit" time="0.171"><skipped type="pytest.skip" message="no Kuadrant WasmPlugin for gateway maas-default-gateway">/workspace/source/test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_subscription.py:941: no Kuadrant WasmPlugin for gateway maas-default-gateway</skipped></testcase><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestUnlimitedSubscription" name="test_unlimited_usage_is_metered" time="25.249" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestAllUnlimitedModel" name="test_all_unlimited_model_is_not_denied" time="20.207" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestMultipleAuthPoliciesPerModel" name="test_two_auth_policies_or_logic" time="27.767" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestMultipleAuthPoliciesPerModel" name="test_delete_one_auth_policy_other_still_works" time="1.257" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestCascadeDeletion" name="test_delete_subscription_rebuilds_trlp" time="17.536" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestCascadeDeletion" name="test_trlp_persists_during_multi_subscription_deletion" time="37.552" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestCascadeDeletion" name="test_delete_last_subscription_denies_access" time="19.191" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestCascadeDeletion" name="test_unconfigured_model_denied_by_gateway_auth" time="0.748" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestRateLimitIdentityGenerations" name="test_legacy_and_short_identities_coexist" time="30.871" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestManagedAnnotation" name="test_authpolicy_managed_false_prevents_update" time="0.327"><skipped type="pytest.skip" message="gateway-only mode: per-model AuthPolicy is not created">/workspace/source/test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_subscription.py:1728: gateway-only mode: per-model AuthPolicy is not created</skipped></testcase><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestManagedAnnotation" name="test_trlp_managed_false_prevents_update" time="305.894"><failure message="TimeoutError: TokenRateLimitPolicy maas-trlp-facebook-opt-125m-simulated was not created and enforced in llm within 300s: generation=1, observedGeneration=1, Enforced={'lastTransitionTime': '2026-11-03T20:42:02Z', 'message': 'TokenRateLimitPolicy waiting for the following components to sync: [Limitador]', 'reason': 'Unknown', 'status': 'False', 'type': 'Enforced'}, includes_subscription=True">self = &lt;test_subscription.TestManagedAnnotation object at 0x7f77e9d10ad0&gt;

    @pytest.mark.serial
    def test_trlp_managed_false_prevents_update(self):
        """TokenRateLimitPolicy annotated with opendatahub.io/managed=false must not
        have its spec updated when the parent MaaSSubscription is modified."""
        ns = _ns()
        trlp_ns = MODEL_NAMESPACE
        parent_snapshot = None
        try:
            # 1. Verify the TRLP exists
            trlp = _get_cr("tokenratelimitpolicy", TRLP_NAME, trlp_ns)
            assert trlp, f"TokenRateLimitPolicy {TRLP_NAME} not found in {trlp_ns}"
    
            # 2. Snapshot the parent MaaSSubscription for cleanup
            parent_snapshot = _snapshot_cr(
                "maassubscription", SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION, ns
            )
            assert parent_snapshot, (
                f"MaaSSubscription {SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION} not found in {ns}"
            )
    
            # 3. Annotate the TRLP with managed=false
            _annotate(
                "tokenratelimitpolicy",
                TRLP_NAME,
                f"{MANAGED_ANNOTATION}=false",
                trlp_ns,
            )
            log.info(
                "Annotated TokenRateLimitPolicy %s with %s=false",
                TRLP_NAME,
                MANAGED_ANNOTATION,
            )
    
            # 4. Re-read the TRLP to capture baseline spec (post-annotation)
            trlp_baseline = _get_cr("tokenratelimitpolicy", TRLP_NAME, trlp_ns)
            assert trlp_baseline, (
                f"TokenRateLimitPolicy {TRLP_NAME} disappeared after annotation"
            )
            baseline_spec = trlp_baseline["spec"]
    
            # 5. Modify the parent MaaSSubscription (change the token rate limit value)
            modified_parent = copy.deepcopy(parent_snapshot)
            model_refs = modified_parent["spec"].get("modelRefs", [])
            assert model_refs, (
                f"MaaSSubscription {SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION} has no modelRefs"
            )
            for ref in model_refs:
                if ref.get("name") == MODEL_REF:
                    limits = ref.get("tokenRateLimits", [])
                    assert limits, f"modelRef {MODEL_REF} has no tokenRateLimits"
                    limits[0]["limit"] = limits[0]["limit"] + 99999
                    break
            else:
                pytest.fail(
                    f"modelRef {MODEL_REF} not found in MaaSSubscription {SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION}"
                )
            _apply_cr(modified_parent)
            log.info(
                "Modified parent MaaSSubscription %s (changed token rate limit)",
                SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION,
            )
    
            # 6. Wait for the controller to reconcile the edited spec
            modified = _get_cr("maassubscription", SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION, ns)
            assert modified, (
                f"MaaSSubscription {SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION} disappeared after update"
            )
            reconciled = _wait_for_subscription_generation_observed(
                SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION,
                modified["metadata"]["generation"],
                namespace=ns,
            )
            # An unchanged TRLP only proves managed=false if the reconcile got
            # to the TRLP step: the model was valid and the step did not fail.
            # Degraded is expected while Kuadrant has not enforced the policy.
            status = reconciled.get("status", {})
            model_ready = any(
                s.get("name") == MODEL_REF and s.get("ready") is True
                for s in status.get("modelRefStatuses", [])
            )
            assert model_ready and status.get("phase") in ("Active", "Degraded"), (
                f"MaaSSubscription {SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION} reconciled without "
                f"reaching the TRLP step: {status}"
            )
    
            # 7. Re-read the TRLP and compare spec
            trlp_after = _get_cr("tokenratelimitpolicy", TRLP_NAME, trlp_ns)
            assert trlp_after, (
                f"TokenRateLimitPolicy {TRLP_NAME} disappeared after parent update"
            )
            after_spec = trlp_after["spec"]
    
            assert baseline_spec == after_spec, (
                f"TokenRateLimitPolicy spec changed despite {MANAGED_ANNOTATION}=false.\n"
                f"Before: {json.dumps(baseline_spec, indent=2)}\n"
                f"After:  {json.dumps(after_spec, indent=2)}"
            )
            log.info(
                "TokenRateLimitPolicy spec unchanged after parent modification — managed=false respected"
            )
    
        finally:
            # Remove the annotation (best-effort so parent restore still runs)
            try:
                _annotate(
                    "tokenratelimitpolicy", TRLP_NAME, f"{MANAGED_ANNOTATION}-", trlp_ns
                )
                log.info(
                    "Removed %s annotation from TokenRateLimitPolicy %s",
                    MANAGED_ANNOTATION,
                    TRLP_NAME,
                )
            except subprocess.CalledProcessError:
                log.warning(
                    "Failed to remove %s annotation from TokenRateLimitPolicy %s (may not exist)",
                    MANAGED_ANNOTATION,
                    TRLP_NAME,
                )
    
            # Restore the parent MaaSSubscription
            if parent_snapshot:
                _apply_cr(parent_snapshot)
                log.info(
                    "Restored parent MaaSSubscription %s from snapshot",
                    SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION,
                )
&gt;               _wait_for_subscription_inference_ready(
                    SIMULATOR_SUBSCRIPTION,
                    MODEL_REF,
                    model_namespace=MODEL_NAMESPACE,
                )

test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_subscription.py:1938: 
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 
test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_helper.py:1833: in _wait_for_subscription_inference_ready
    _wait_for_token_rate_limit_policy(
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 

model_ref = 'facebook-opt-125m-simulated', model_namespace = 'llm'
timeout = 300, subscription_name = 'simulator-subscription'
subscription_namespace = 'models-as-a-service'

    def _wait_for_token_rate_limit_policy(
        model_ref, model_namespace=MODEL_NAMESPACE, timeout=180, *, subscription_name=None, subscription_namespace=None
    ):
        """Wait for the current TokenRateLimitPolicy generation to be enforced.
    
        If a subscription is supplied, wait until the policy includes it. This
        prevents accepting the old policy before the controller updates its spec.
    
        Args:
            model_ref: Name of the model (e.g., "e2e-distinct-simulated")
            model_namespace: Namespace where the TRLP should be created (default: MODEL_NAMESPACE)
            timeout: Maximum wait time in seconds (default: 180)
            subscription_name: Subscription that the policy must include, if supplied
            subscription_namespace: Subscription namespace (defaults to _ns())
    
        Raises:
            TimeoutError: If TRLP isn't created and enforced within timeout
        """
        trlp_name = f"maas-trlp-{model_ref}"
        expected_subscription = (
            f"{subscription_namespace or _ns()}/{subscription_name}" if subscription_name else None
        )
        last_snapshot = "not found"
        deadline = time.time() + timeout
        log.info(f"Waiting for TokenRateLimitPolicy {trlp_name} in {model_namespace} (timeout: {timeout}s)...")
    
        while time.time() &lt; deadline:
            result = subprocess.run(
                ["oc", "get", "tokenratelimitpolicy", trlp_name, "-n", model_namespace, "-o", "json"],
                capture_output=True,
                text=True,
                timeout=30,
            )
            if result.returncode == 0:
                try:
                    trlp = json.loads(result.stdout)
                    metadata = trlp.get("metadata", {})
                    status = trlp.get("status", {})
                    generation = metadata.get("generation")
                    observed = status.get("observedGeneration")
                    conditions = status.get("conditions", [])
                    enforced = next((c for c in conditions if c.get("type") == "Enforced"), None)
                    subscriptions = {
                        name.strip()
                        for name in metadata.get("annotations", {}).get(
                            "maas.opendatahub.io/subscriptions", ""
                        ).split(",")
                    }
                    includes_subscription = expected_subscription is None or expected_subscription in subscriptions
                    last_snapshot = (
                        f"generation={generation}, observedGeneration={observed}, "
                        f"Enforced={enforced}, includes_subscription={includes_subscription}"
                    )
                    if (
                        enforced and enforced.get("status") == "True"
                        and generation is not None and observed == generation
                        and includes_subscription
                    ):
                        log.info(f"TokenRateLimitPolicy {trlp_name} generation {generation} is enforced")
                        return
                    log.debug(f"TokenRateLimitPolicy {trlp_name} is not ready: {last_snapshot}")
                except (json.JSONDecodeError, KeyError) as e:
                    log.debug(f"Failed to parse TRLP status: {e}")
            elif _is_not_found_error(result.stderr):
                log.debug(f"TokenRateLimitPolicy {trlp_name} not found yet...")
            elif _is_transient_kubectl_error(result.stderr):
                log.debug(
                    f"Transient error while reading TokenRateLimitPolicy {trlp_name}: {result.stderr.strip()}"
                )
            else:
                raise RuntimeError(
                    f"Failed to get TokenRateLimitPolicy {trlp_name} in namespace '{model_namespace}': "
                    f"{result.stderr.strip()}"
                )
            time.sleep(3)
    
&gt;       raise TimeoutError(
            f"TokenRateLimitPolicy {trlp_name} was not created and enforced in {model_namespace} within {timeout}s: {last_snapshot}"
        )
E       TimeoutError: TokenRateLimitPolicy maas-trlp-facebook-opt-125m-simulated was not created and enforced in llm within 300s: generation=1, observedGeneration=1, Enforced={'lastTransitionTime': '2026-11-03T20:42:02Z', 'message': 'TokenRateLimitPolicy waiting for the following components to sync: [Limitador]', 'reason': 'Unknown', 'status': 'False', 'type': 'Enforced'}, includes_subscription=True

test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_helper.py:1575: TimeoutError</failure></testcase><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestE2ESubscriptionFlow" name="test_e2e_with_access_but_no_subscription_gets_403" time="19.273" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestE2ESubscriptionFlow" name="test_e2e_single_subscription_auto_selects" time="81.053" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestE2ESubscriptionFlow" name="test_e2e_group_based_auth_but_no_subscription_gets_403" time="21.896" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestStatusReporting" name="test_subscription_degraded_trlp_blocks_inference" time="103.511" /><testcase classname="tests.test_subscription.TestDegradedSubscriptionFiltering" name="test_failed_subscription_blocks_inference" time="18.959" /><testcase classname="tests.test_models_endpoint.TestModelsEndpoint" name="test_single_subscription_auto_select" time="100.880" /><testcase classname="tests.test_models_endpoint.TestModelsEndpoint" name="test_explicit_subscription_header" time="1.394" /><testcase classname="tests.test_models_endpoint.TestModelsEndpoint" name="test_models_filtered_by_subscription" time="1.467" /><testcase classname="tests.test_models_endpoint.TestModelsEndpoint" name="test_different_modelrefs_same_model_id" time="46.486" /><testcase classname="tests.test_models_endpoint.TestModelsEndpoint" name="test_empty_model_list" time="11.266" /><testcase classname="tests.test_models_endpoint.TestModelsEndpoint" name="test_central_models_endpoint_exempt_from_rate_limiting" time="22.047" /><testcase classname="tests.test_tenant.TestTenantLifecycle" name="test_payload_processing_deployed_with_active_tenant" time="17.230" /><testcase classname="tests.test_tenant.TestTenantLifecycle" name="test_payload_processing_and_pre_processing_resources" time="0.310"><skipped type="pytest.skip" message="default payload-processing is praxis-extproc; MaasTenantConfig.spec.payloadProcessing.resources is MaaS IPP-only">/workspace/source/test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_tenant.py:401: default payload-processing is praxis-extproc; MaasTenantConfig.spec.payloadProcessing.resources is MaaS IPP-only</skipped></testcase><testcase classname="tests.test_aitenant_lifecycle.TestAITenantRevocationOperandsSerial" name="test_aitenant_delete_completes_after_cleanup_serviceaccount_removed" time="37.026" /><testcase classname="tests.test_tenant_namespace_discovery.TestTenantDiscoveryDormantMode" name="test_dormant_mode_ignores_labeled_namespace" time="0.453"><skipped type="pytest.skip" message="Dormant-mode test mutates controller flags; set ENABLE_TENANT_DISCOVERY_DORMANT_E2E=true">/workspace/source/test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_tenant_namespace_discovery.py:359: Dormant-mode test mutates controller flags; set ENABLE_TENANT_DISCOVERY_DORMANT_E2E=true</skipped></testcase><testcase classname="tests.test_multi_tenant_maas_api.TestPerTenantMaaSAPI" name="test_dual_listeners_keep_one_authconfig_per_route_rule" time="38.421"><failure message="AssertionError: Expected exactly one Ready and Available non-deleting Authorino AuthConfig per rule for odh-ai-gateway-infra/maas-api-route-e2e-authcfg-http-0fe875; got {'rule-1': [('0bc188dd8bd13a04bacf43ea914baa3c293018b7e7aa050bbacfb702a05d64bf', '6768f71a-3b24-4ab8-bd8b-b9fc2e85c584', True), ('9f43bfee860b5cb735651a287856d707458ed04ff5c7725536362a4325eaf0d0', 'aae898c7-4e1b-4319-b6b8-8d32f56d23d0', True)], 'rule-6': [('147afb3378b258c4dafa0becdc07b452a1deccf3733d47bc0e5f747aa64adf20', '1aa6f...&#10;[+2 more lines; full report in element text]">self = &lt;test_multi_tenant_maas_api.TestPerTenantMaaSAPI object at 0x7f77e9bafa90&gt;
dual_listener_tenant_case = {'suffix': '0fe875', 'tenant_ns': 'ai-tenant-e2e-authcfg-http-0fe875', 'tenant_label_name': 'e2e-authcfg-http-0fe875', 'gateway_name': 'e2e-authcfg-http-0fe875', ...}

    @pytest.mark.nightly
    @pytest.mark.serial
    def test_dual_listeners_keep_one_authconfig_per_route_rule(self, dual_listener_tenant_case):
        """One stable Authorino AuthConfig per rule when both listeners attach the route."""
        case = dual_listener_tenant_case
        gateway = wait_for_json(
            "gateway",
            case["gateway_name"],
            GATEWAY_NAMESPACE,
            predicate=lambda obj: {"http", "https"}
            &lt;= _gateway_listener_names_with_routes(obj),
            timeout=180,
        )
        listeners = {
            listener.get("name"): listener
            for listener in (gateway.get("spec") or {}).get("listeners") or []
        }
        assert {"http", "https"} &lt;= set(listeners), (
            f"{case['gateway_name']} must have both HTTP and HTTPS listeners, got {listeners!r}"
        )
        assert listeners["http"].get("protocol") == "HTTP" and listeners["http"].get("port") == 80
        assert listeners["https"].get("protocol") == "HTTPS" and listeners["https"].get("port") == 443
        assert listeners["http"].get("hostname") == listeners["https"].get("hostname"), (
            f"Test setup must use a shared hostname across listeners: {listeners!r}"
        )
    
        route_name = _tenant_api_names(case)["httproute"]
        route = wait_for_json(
            "httproute",
            route_name,
            INFRA_NAMESPACE,
            predicate=lambda obj: _route_accepted_by_gateway(obj, case["gateway_name"]),
            timeout=180,
        )
        authconfigs_by_rule = _wait_for_stable_route_authconfigs(route)
        rules = (route.get("spec") or {}).get("rules") or []
        expected_rules = {f"rule-{index}" for index in range(1, len(rules) + 1)}
        assert set(authconfigs_by_rule) == expected_rules
&gt;       assert all(
            len(observations) == 1 and observations[0][2]
            for observations in authconfigs_by_rule.values()
        ), (
            f"Expected exactly one Ready and Available non-deleting Authorino "
            f"AuthConfig per rule for "
            f"{INFRA_NAMESPACE}/{route_name}; got {authconfigs_by_rule!r}"
        )
E       AssertionError: Expected exactly one Ready and Available non-deleting Authorino AuthConfig per rule for odh-ai-gateway-infra/maas-api-route-e2e-authcfg-http-0fe875; got {'rule-1': [('0bc188dd8bd13a04bacf43ea914baa3c293018b7e7aa050bbacfb702a05d64bf', '6768f71a-3b24-4ab8-bd8b-b9fc2e85c584', True), ('9f43bfee860b5cb735651a287856d707458ed04ff5c7725536362a4325eaf0d0', 'aae898c7-4e1b-4319-b6b8-8d32f56d23d0', True)], 'rule-6': [('147afb3378b258c4dafa0becdc07b452a1deccf3733d47bc0e5f747aa64adf20', '1aa6f071-70db-46bc-8cbd-650fb403f7f9', True), ('db335c69f82b117c58c686b17fe8bdef5dd5bbfa2e82db5c8acc2fb35e64a5eb', '8e1c44e9-fda2-4764-9ba3-13bfa035ad18', True)], 'rule-2': [('19e510d54a073923ad8e953a1d323bf2f588f409e7a61a97f3a57fce667b62fe', '61ce4300-0bb1-4964-9735-841eb19b4215', True), ('e1face630d5ea453c77cfe0d627bc0bd01cadefcd5a10d95f168b5a707aa15e2', '8b3b737c-a59d-4539-94b5-bf3712705cdc', True)], 'rule-3': [('1a0b02a13bfca8cf32197075b48910ff5e446750df446c3a023f6a68491060ac', 'ec005c91-d4d5-44ef-97c4-6245f71f02bb', True), ('9c6ce1ed8aa1ec645d4230e5c93f333638ca3753c53302d5fe47ad7a82166345', '6fd12e69-e3a1-43f9-bf40-7770d780c260', True)], 'rule-4': [('460a54a58fe05c0669d3f9a684fe964d1da9467dff1d440843729c9a6f84c6a0', '5f267e6e-0785-4b71-9fad-2f68e61c63d3', True), ('6b6addd730d7526b6e309546ad53cd5d63824751ac229c552ac287ac7bdef4e7', 'cfa5a241-a994-41d0-a964-cf5a1bd54ad0', True)], 'rule-5': [('d1e1be4f1cff78c53cdea297ddfce6ec5d2acc471e528f3a9b465e693f76bb5d', '98aee5e9-e34b-45be-b0b3-b9adab64c118', True), ('fd798c8eb31c7233f778774ddd035e92217c3545473d13c7d8b281ef094157ad', 'e128a659-1742-4b0d-acb1-f84326a1fb03', True)]}
E       assert False
E        +  where False = all(&lt;generator object TestPerTenantMaaSAPI.test_dual_listeners_keep_one_authconfig_per_route_rule.&lt;locals&gt;.&lt;genexpr&gt; at 0x7f77e9dd58c0&gt;)

test/maas-e2e/test/e2e/tests/test_multi_tenant_maas_api.py:381: AssertionError</failure></testcase><testcase classname="tests.test_multi_tenant_maas_api.TestPerTenantMaaSAPI" name="test_dual_listener_wasm_envoyfilter_generation_stays_stable" time="84.456" /><testcase classname="tests.test_embedding_inference.TestEmbeddingDefaultDeny" name="test_embedding_default_deny_403" time="0.288" /><testcase classname="tests.test_embedding_inference.TestEmbeddingPathRouting" name="test_embedding_path_based_200" time="5.107" /><testcase classname="tests.test_embedding_inference.TestEmbeddingPathRouting" name="test_embedding_bbr_llmisvc_200" time="0.422" /><testcase classname="tests.test_embedding_inference.TestEmbeddingGovernance" name="test_embedding_trlp_429" time="16.362" /><testcase classname="tests.test_embedding_inference.TestEmbeddingGovernance" name="test_embedding_with_governance_200" time="26.666" /></testsuite></testsuites>